News Reality

Liz Lemon's Feminism, 10 Years Later

by www.huffingtonpost.com

Ten years ago, Liz Lemon, a character created and played by Tina Fey, shuffled onto our screens in the first episode of “30 Rock.”

Liz Lemon was a “bad feminist.” That’s what made her so compelling. In the 2006 television comedy landscape that lacked for an abundance of truly vibrant female leads, she was an entirely new breed. She was the head writer of the fictional sketch show “TGS.” She was a “boss,” though unabashedly un-bosslike. She was neurotic, ungraceful, ornery and deliberately flawed. 

With Tina Fey’s distinct brand of absurdist and ironic humor, “30 Rock” often challenged stereotypes about women by either parodying them to the extreme (in the case of Jenna Maroney, played by Jane Krakowski) or subverting them with Lemon’s character herself. 

Lemon was the Mary Tyler Moore for a new age: single and not wild about it but also far more happy eating a sandwich than going on a date. By the end of the series in 2013, she “has it all” on her own terms ? a loving husband, kids, and an executive producer position on a popular new show. 

Over seven seasons, “30 Rock” both subtlety and implicitly tackled a whole host of feminist issues, from reproductive rights to sexism in the workplace. The episode “The C Word,” where Liz is shocked when she overhears Lutz complaining about her bossiness, is inspired by a time Fey was actually called a c**t by comedian Colin Quinn when she was head writer on “SNL.” (She discussed the incident on an episode of “The Howard Stern Show,” and Quinn himself later confirmed it via Twitter). 

And yet, while Lemon was anointed as a kind of feminist TV icon with her arrival on the TV scene, “30 Rock” has always had a complicated relationship with gender and the “feminist” label that’s been largely thrust upon it. For all the praise the series received for presenting a strong, unique comedic female lead, it also received some sharp criticisms. 

Of course, when a woman endeavors to do anything, she’s usually opened up for way more scrutiny than a man ? even more when she’s hailed as a feminist hero. Still, a lot of the criticism leveled against Fey and “30 Rock” wasn’t nitpicking. Some complained that Lemon’s power had gradually diminished over the course of the show, the “strong female lead” character becoming more dependent on CEO Jack Donaghy’s guidance and advice rather than on her own boss-lady intuition. Others called Fey out for the show’s penchant for slamming “sluts,” “whores” and sex workers in the form of various off-color jokes.  

The show addressed some of these feminist criticisms in Season 5. In an episode titled “TGS Hates Women,” Liz becomes so obsessed with freeing her feminism-challenged colleague “sexy baby” from the patriarchy that she inadvertently slut-shames her out of the witness protection program.

Meanwhile, Jenna stars in a sketch in which, dressed as Hillary Clinton about to give a state address, she clenches her stomach and groans, “Oh no, my period. Let’s nuke England!”

Later in the episode, a website called JoanofSnark.com (a parody of feminist site Jezebel) publishes an essay accusing “TGS” of hating women. Lemon is shocked that her favorite site would call her work unfeminist.

When confronted with the sexist nature of the period sketch, Lemon feebly defends it as an “ironic reappropriation,” then concedes that she doesn’t know anymore what’s satire and what isn’t. 

It’s an interesting moment of self-awareness on the show, punctuated by a classic “30 Rock” comedic twist as Lemon, realizing that she may not be as “feminist” as she thought, clutches her stomach and shouts, “Ugh, my period! You’re all fired!”

The series wasn’t always this successful or self-aware ? the same season opened with a rape joke and scene in which Pete creepily has sex with his unconscious wife. In its earlier years, the show relied on a brand of humor that would be far more susceptible to scrutiny by its later seasons. And “30 Rock’s” sporadic self-awareness is a huge marker of its datedness, at least when it comes to conversations about identity in pop culture. 

Many episodes throughout all seven seasons are still funny, still vibrant, and still speak to being a “modern woman” today. But in many ways “30 Rock” doesn’t quite hold up in 2016. It premiered in 2006 when merely convincing people that women are funny was a hurdle. Critical discussions about television and pop culture that shifted drastically throughout “30 Rock’s” seven-year run have grown louder and more urgent since the 2013 finale. 

Today, the concepts of diversity, inclusion and intersectionality rule how we consume and consider our pop culture, and while some might consider these concepts as nothing more than buzzwords, they’ve largely dictated the television landscape as it exists today. Liz Lemon, it’s safe to say, was also not an intersectional feminist.

Indeed, Lemon and Fey have been largely alienating to women (especially women of color) who feel they have no access to their narratives, who aren’t impressed or empowered by the idea that Liz Lemon is revolutionary because she likes to eat and is supposed to be seen as “frumpy” based on an incredibly Eurocentric standard of beauty. 

Equally alienating are the transphobic jokes, most blatant in the use of trans slurs and jokes surrounding Jenna’s boyfriend Paul, and the constant stream of racial humor that was far too hit or miss. 

“30 Rock’s” writers often lampooned Lemon and her obliviousness to everyday racism. Other times, as in the case of Tracy Jordan (and his “sassy” wife, played by Sherri Shepherd), it was unclear if the stereotypical characterizations of non-white characters were truly subversive or simply reinforcing the kind of liberal racism that defends even the most offensive bit, such as the show’s consistent use of blackface, as “ironic.”

In intervening years, Liz Lemon has become a stereotype herself: the embodiment of the 40-something white feminist.  

In the pilot episode of “30 Rock,” Jack Donaghy and Liz Lemon meet. He sizes her up, and sums up who she is in one sentence:

“New York, third-wave feminist, college-educated, single and pretending to be happy about it, over-scheduled, under sexed, you buy any magazine that says ‘healthy body image’ on the cover, and every two years you take up knitting for a week.”

The line is a perfect simultaneous summation of what made Liz Lemon exciting when she first came on the scene, and what makes her kind of a relic now. 

“30 Rock” is dated, at least in the sphere of so-called “feminist TV,” but in spite of all its problems, the most significant thing that it did for TV was cement the idea of a female comedy showrunner. 

Fey presented a style of comedy, an aesthetic, and a tone that was distinct to her, distinct in a way that lent itself to the kind of thoughtful criticism and rigorous debate that in the past has usually only been afforded to the work of male writers. As NPR writer Linda Holmes argued in 2012 “the entire idea of a woman having a comedy brand that translated to comedic opportunities for people other than herself” was almost unheard of before “30 Rock.” 

This isn’t to give Fey too much credit, or forgive her for her tendency to blatantly disregard and dismiss valid critiques.  Her flaws, especially in regards to race, continue even now (on “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt”), and while she’s often game enough to address her critics in her own work she rarely ever engages in a way that suggests she’s actually considering the criticism fully.   

Still. It’s those very criticisms of “30 Rock” and the shows that arguably came out of its popularity (”Parks and Recreation,” “Girls,” “Inside Amy Schumer,” “Broad City”) that opened up conversations about the need for women who aren’t white, straight, and middle-class in comedy. “30 Rock” set a trend in women-led TV comedy that was distressingly white ? so white that it emphasized a need for more shows willing to acknowledge and grapple with their own blind spots about race.

Today, watching “30 Rock” presents a stark contrast to shows like “Brooklyn 99,” “Angie Tribeca,” “The Mindy Project,” “Jane the Virgin,” “Orange is the New Black,” “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend,” and, most recently, Issa Rae’s hilarious “Insecure.” All of these shows have their strengths and their flaws, with some succeeding in the arbitrary realm of what is truly “feminist” more than others.

Ten years later, the beauty of Liz Lemon is that you don’t have to like her, or identify with her, or think she’s funny. One can criticize her character and what she represents without feeling as though it’s a critique on all women.

Ten years later, “30 Rock” serves as a reminder of how far we’ve come when it comes to depictions of women on TV, and how much farther we have to go. 

-- This feed and its contents are the property of The Huffington Post, and use is subject to our terms. It may be used for personal consumption, but may not be distributed on a website.


Read Full Article On www.huffingtonpost.com
Latest
Photographer Gina Lee captured her children as Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling in the Oscar-nominated film.
Officials believe an early morning fire at a mosque in Florida was intentionally set, and the incident is being investigated as a hate crime.
Coronation Street teased that all could be revealed tonight as Steve was left holding baby Oliver when things turned chaotic. Leanne was at The Bistro with partner Nick Tilsley and their family to
The band celebrated the news at their first gig in one-and-a-half years.
Comedian Bill Maher felt proud of himself after the downfall of former Breitbart editor and alt-right provocateur Milo Yiannopoulos. Last Friday, Yiannopoulos appeared on "Real Time with Bill Maher."
“Early on, people would say that their wives could probably do what I did.” Colleen Atwood laughed softly into the phone as she spoke of her career as one of the most Oscar-celebrated costume desi
Few people know how to navigate a crowd quite like Sergei Loznitsa. Whether he’s using a carefully positioned tripod or thrusting his handheld camera directly into the fray, the Belarus-born Ukrai
La La Land – starring Miles Teller and Emma Watson as Sebastian and Mia, instead of Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone?
Japanese animator Hayao Miyazaki has come out of retirement and begun working on a feature film, according to a Studio Ghibli producer.
Students queued for several hours to be part of an intimate audience with the cinematic legend.
Oscar nominee Casey Affleck may be at the top of his game now,
In a typical sci-fi movie about extraterrestrials, there are certain kinds of sounds you’d expect to hear: electronic bleeps and bloops, whooshing spaceships, the slithering of slimy aliens, some
Today in Entertainment: Prominent Iranian Americans will represent Asghar Farhadi at Oscars; New 'Twin Peaks' art Feb. 24, 2017, 12:08 p.m. With the Oscars around the corner and much of Hollywood
  SUNDAY The musical “La La Land” leads the field with 14 nominations at the 89th Academy Awards, a.k.a. “The Oscars.” Jimmy Kimmel serves as master of ceremonies at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood
Taylor Nolan, a 23-year-old mental health counselor from Seattle, seemed to click with Nick Viall early in this season of “The Bachelor.” Soon, however, she got swept up in a bitter feud
Paul Schimmel, the longtime Los Angeles curator best known for his defining tenure as the former chief curator at the Museum of Contemporary Art Los Angeles, has departed Hauser Wirth & Schimmel,
Raymond Kohn of the Northeast Ohio Dukes leaps a General Lee behind Cobo Center to open the 2017 Autorama.        
Tina has recently been looking after her mother Sylvie who suffers with dementia, and as been struggling with the responsibility. The character split with girlfriend Sonia Jackson last year, and he
Gene Clark — a founding member of the Byrds whose musical legacy is often overshadowed by those of his onetime bandmates Roger McGuinn, David Crosby, Chris Hillman, Clarence White and latter-day m
PHILADELPHIA (AP) — In a major break for Bill Cosby, a judge ruled Friday that just one of the comedian's multitude of other accusers can testify at his trial to bolster charges he drugged and violate
All the stars will be in town for the 89th Academy Awards on Sunday February 26. But which LA venues will they be partying in?
To hear Olivia Harrison tell it, it wasn’t unusual for George Harrison to stroll through their house spouting words at random — a process that could cause an outsider to wonder whether the ex-Beat
Donald Trump and his administration are telling the country that the Americans protesting him are being paid to do so. But if that’s true, some protestors are left wondering, “Where the f*
As Leslie Jones knows all too well, laughter is the best revenge.  The “Saturday Night Live” star addressed the hack of her personal website last year during what
In the first scene of “La La Land,” a diverse group of Los Angeles residents break out into an upbeat song and dance number in the middle of a traffic jam on the freeway. The scene
It's his fifth time addressing the gathering.
Comedian Peter Kay will be stepping into the role at the last minute.
Trump did not hold back when live-tweeting past Oscar ceremonies.
Lewis Bloor launched an online tirade at Aaron Chalmers on Twitter[Wenn] Aaron and Marnie famously dated on and off during Geordie Shore. But their fling soon ended and  Marnie went o
Hollywood insiders look back at some of the most politically-charged speeches.
ABC News' Lesley Messer gives us a behind the scenes look at the floral arrangements being prepared by Mark's Garden for the Oscars Governors Ball.
function onPlayerReadyVidible(e){'undefined'!=typeof HPTrack&&HPTrack.Vid.Vidible_track(e)}!function(e,i){if(e.vdb_Player){if('object'==typeof commercial_video){var a='',o='m.fwsitesection='+commer
"Mad Men" stars Jon Hamm, January Jones, Christina Hendricks, Kiernan Shipka and Jessica Pare attended series creator Matthew Weiner's book launch.

Recent News

East Africa to track trucks from Mombasa port to stop theft

Uganda, Kenya and Rwanda adopt a truck-tracking system to prevent theft and speed up goods in transit.
Read Full Article

Lesotho's 'pilot' fruit and flower farm

As part of a World Bank pilot programme, smallholders in Lesotho have been offered a stake in a commercial venture.
Read Full Article

Volkswagen looks to cap executive pay, bonuses

Company looks to quell widespread anger over bonuses paid even as it suffered record losses
Read Full Article

Leaves EU consumer chief 'desperate' over dieselgate

Volkswagen's cheating led Germany to order an EU-wide recall of 8.5 million Volkswagen vehicles
Read Full Article

Samsung tightens donation rules after scandal

President Jay Y Lee is accused of pledging 43 bn won in bribes to a company
Read Full Article

VX nerve agent killed Kim Jong Nam

The United Nations classifies the chemical as a weapon of mass destruction
Read Full Article

US to seek extradition of ex-Guatemalan vice-president

GUATEMALA CITY - The United States government will seek the extradition of former Guatemalan Vice-President Roxana Baldetti and ex-Interior Minister Hector Mauricio Lopez Bonilla on drug trafficking c
Read Full Article

Japanese cult also used VX; survivor recounts how it felt

TOKYO - A Japanese religious cult that carried out a deadly nerve gas attack on Tokyo's subways in 1995 also experimented with the VX nerve agent suspected in the killing of North Korean leader Kim Jo
Read Full Article

Less-Abominable Snowmobiles

Snow mobiles may have a big, bad reputation, but these sleek, new-breed racers offer a quieter, more environmentally friendly ride.
Read Full Article

Popular Finance

Gov. Jerry Brown proposes $437-million fix for flood control and emergency response needs

Essential Politics: California Republicans gather for their state convention in Sacramento Feb. 24, 2017, 12:39 p.m. This is Essential Politics, our daily look at California political and governme
Read Full Article

Arizona Republicans want to apply racketeering law to protests. Can someone introduce them to the 1st Amendment?

How’s this for a laughable — were it not so serious — proposed law? Arizona legislators want to make organizers and participants in planned peaceful protests subject to racketeering laws if violen
Read Full Article

Trump blasts FBI over Russia leaks after a brief Twitter hiatus

At conservative gathering, Trump tries to define a new GOP Feb. 24, 2017, 11:56 a.m. A look at President Trump's administration and the rest of Washington: At CPAC, president calls for Republican
Read Full Article

Herbert Fink, hipster who helped make Rodeo Drive a fashion destination, dies at 93

When Herbert Fink set up shop on Rodeo Drive, it was an unremarkable side street dotted with filling stations, a hardware shop, a few old bungalows and an aging Brown Derby restaurant. He stocked
Read Full Article

Gov. Jerry Brown proposes speeding up water and flood-protection projects after the winter's big storms

Essential Politics: California Republicans gather for their state convention in Sacramento Feb. 24, 2017, 12:39 p.m. This is Essential Politics, our daily look at California political and governme
Read Full Article

Gripped by fear of ICE raids and deportations, one town tries to separate fact from rumor

The housekeeper panicked when she heard about Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents descending on Santa Paula.  The 40-year-old, a Mexican immigrant in the U.S. illegally, called her boss and
Read Full Article

CSU students told to call campus cops if stopped by immigration officers

Essential Education: Financial aid applications are due in less than a week Feb. 24, 2017, 12:28 p.m. Welcome to Essential Education, our daily look at education in California and beyond. Here's t
Read Full Article

Conflict or cooperation with President Trump? Gov. Jerry Brown sees an opportunity for both

Essential Politics: California Republicans gather for their state convention in Sacramento Feb. 24, 2017, 12:39 p.m. This is Essential Politics, our daily look at California political and governme
Read Full Article

Calendar Letters: Life-changing books

I wept as I read Rigoberto Gonzalez’s  moving essay about the importance of books as he was growing up [“The Power of the Printed Word,” Feb. 19]. The library was my salvation during a challenging
Read Full Article