News Reality

Liz Lemon's Feminism, 10 Years Later

by www.huffingtonpost.com

Ten years ago, Liz Lemon, a character created and played by Tina Fey, shuffled onto our screens in the first episode of “30 Rock.”

Liz Lemon was a “bad feminist.” That’s what made her so compelling. In the 2006 television comedy landscape that lacked for an abundance of truly vibrant female leads, she was an entirely new breed. She was the head writer of the fictional sketch show “TGS.” She was a “boss,” though unabashedly un-bosslike. She was neurotic, ungraceful, ornery and deliberately flawed. 

With Tina Fey’s distinct brand of absurdist and ironic humor, “30 Rock” often challenged stereotypes about women by either parodying them to the extreme (in the case of Jenna Maroney, played by Jane Krakowski) or subverting them with Lemon’s character herself. 

Lemon was the Mary Tyler Moore for a new age: single and not wild about it but also far more happy eating a sandwich than going on a date. By the end of the series in 2013, she “has it all” on her own terms ? a loving husband, kids, and an executive producer position on a popular new show. 

Over seven seasons, “30 Rock” both subtlety and implicitly tackled a whole host of feminist issues, from reproductive rights to sexism in the workplace. The episode “The C Word,” where Liz is shocked when she overhears Lutz complaining about her bossiness, is inspired by a time Fey was actually called a c**t by comedian Colin Quinn when she was head writer on “SNL.” (She discussed the incident on an episode of “The Howard Stern Show,” and Quinn himself later confirmed it via Twitter). 

And yet, while Lemon was anointed as a kind of feminist TV icon with her arrival on the TV scene, “30 Rock” has always had a complicated relationship with gender and the “feminist” label that’s been largely thrust upon it. For all the praise the series received for presenting a strong, unique comedic female lead, it also received some sharp criticisms. 

Of course, when a woman endeavors to do anything, she’s usually opened up for way more scrutiny than a man ? even more when she’s hailed as a feminist hero. Still, a lot of the criticism leveled against Fey and “30 Rock” wasn’t nitpicking. Some complained that Lemon’s power had gradually diminished over the course of the show, the “strong female lead” character becoming more dependent on CEO Jack Donaghy’s guidance and advice rather than on her own boss-lady intuition. Others called Fey out for the show’s penchant for slamming “sluts,” “whores” and sex workers in the form of various off-color jokes.  

The show addressed some of these feminist criticisms in Season 5. In an episode titled “TGS Hates Women,” Liz becomes so obsessed with freeing her feminism-challenged colleague “sexy baby” from the patriarchy that she inadvertently slut-shames her out of the witness protection program.

Meanwhile, Jenna stars in a sketch in which, dressed as Hillary Clinton about to give a state address, she clenches her stomach and groans, “Oh no, my period. Let’s nuke England!”

Later in the episode, a website called JoanofSnark.com (a parody of feminist site Jezebel) publishes an essay accusing “TGS” of hating women. Lemon is shocked that her favorite site would call her work unfeminist.

When confronted with the sexist nature of the period sketch, Lemon feebly defends it as an “ironic reappropriation,” then concedes that she doesn’t know anymore what’s satire and what isn’t. 

It’s an interesting moment of self-awareness on the show, punctuated by a classic “30 Rock” comedic twist as Lemon, realizing that she may not be as “feminist” as she thought, clutches her stomach and shouts, “Ugh, my period! You’re all fired!”

The series wasn’t always this successful or self-aware ? the same season opened with a rape joke and scene in which Pete creepily has sex with his unconscious wife. In its earlier years, the show relied on a brand of humor that would be far more susceptible to scrutiny by its later seasons. And “30 Rock’s” sporadic self-awareness is a huge marker of its datedness, at least when it comes to conversations about identity in pop culture. 

Many episodes throughout all seven seasons are still funny, still vibrant, and still speak to being a “modern woman” today. But in many ways “30 Rock” doesn’t quite hold up in 2016. It premiered in 2006 when merely convincing people that women are funny was a hurdle. Critical discussions about television and pop culture that shifted drastically throughout “30 Rock’s” seven-year run have grown louder and more urgent since the 2013 finale. 

Today, the concepts of diversity, inclusion and intersectionality rule how we consume and consider our pop culture, and while some might consider these concepts as nothing more than buzzwords, they’ve largely dictated the television landscape as it exists today. Liz Lemon, it’s safe to say, was also not an intersectional feminist.

Indeed, Lemon and Fey have been largely alienating to women (especially women of color) who feel they have no access to their narratives, who aren’t impressed or empowered by the idea that Liz Lemon is revolutionary because she likes to eat and is supposed to be seen as “frumpy” based on an incredibly Eurocentric standard of beauty. 

Equally alienating are the transphobic jokes, most blatant in the use of trans slurs and jokes surrounding Jenna’s boyfriend Paul, and the constant stream of racial humor that was far too hit or miss. 

“30 Rock’s” writers often lampooned Lemon and her obliviousness to everyday racism. Other times, as in the case of Tracy Jordan (and his “sassy” wife, played by Sherri Shepherd), it was unclear if the stereotypical characterizations of non-white characters were truly subversive or simply reinforcing the kind of liberal racism that defends even the most offensive bit, such as the show’s consistent use of blackface, as “ironic.”

In intervening years, Liz Lemon has become a stereotype herself: the embodiment of the 40-something white feminist.  

In the pilot episode of “30 Rock,” Jack Donaghy and Liz Lemon meet. He sizes her up, and sums up who she is in one sentence:

“New York, third-wave feminist, college-educated, single and pretending to be happy about it, over-scheduled, under sexed, you buy any magazine that says ‘healthy body image’ on the cover, and every two years you take up knitting for a week.”

The line is a perfect simultaneous summation of what made Liz Lemon exciting when she first came on the scene, and what makes her kind of a relic now. 

“30 Rock” is dated, at least in the sphere of so-called “feminist TV,” but in spite of all its problems, the most significant thing that it did for TV was cement the idea of a female comedy showrunner. 

Fey presented a style of comedy, an aesthetic, and a tone that was distinct to her, distinct in a way that lent itself to the kind of thoughtful criticism and rigorous debate that in the past has usually only been afforded to the work of male writers. As NPR writer Linda Holmes argued in 2012 “the entire idea of a woman having a comedy brand that translated to comedic opportunities for people other than herself” was almost unheard of before “30 Rock.” 

This isn’t to give Fey too much credit, or forgive her for her tendency to blatantly disregard and dismiss valid critiques.  Her flaws, especially in regards to race, continue even now (on “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt”), and while she’s often game enough to address her critics in her own work she rarely ever engages in a way that suggests she’s actually considering the criticism fully.   

Still. It’s those very criticisms of “30 Rock” and the shows that arguably came out of its popularity (”Parks and Recreation,” “Girls,” “Inside Amy Schumer,” “Broad City”) that opened up conversations about the need for women who aren’t white, straight, and middle-class in comedy. “30 Rock” set a trend in women-led TV comedy that was distressingly white ? so white that it emphasized a need for more shows willing to acknowledge and grapple with their own blind spots about race.

Today, watching “30 Rock” presents a stark contrast to shows like “Brooklyn 99,” “Angie Tribeca,” “The Mindy Project,” “Jane the Virgin,” “Orange is the New Black,” “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend,” and, most recently, Issa Rae’s hilarious “Insecure.” All of these shows have their strengths and their flaws, with some succeeding in the arbitrary realm of what is truly “feminist” more than others.

Ten years later, the beauty of Liz Lemon is that you don’t have to like her, or identify with her, or think she’s funny. One can criticize her character and what she represents without feeling as though it’s a critique on all women.

Ten years later, “30 Rock” serves as a reminder of how far we’ve come when it comes to depictions of women on TV, and how much farther we have to go. 

-- This feed and its contents are the property of The Huffington Post, and use is subject to our terms. It may be used for personal consumption, but may not be distributed on a website.


Read Full Article On www.huffingtonpost.com
Latest
She said she tried to communicate with her family while in a coma.
You’ve missed your chance to own these choice items from the acclaimed film’s set.
It was a tale as old as time at Friday’s box office, as Disney’s “Beauty and the Beast” once again climbed into the top spot. The live-action remake of the animated classic starring Emma Watson an
Four plays will start in Nicosia over the next few days and give Nicosians a chance to catch stories of drama, longing, anguish and passion. The Egomio Cultural Centre has two plays coming up. The fi
The wait is over. After a week of teases from director Zack Snyder and others, we have a full "Justice League" trailer to compliment the one we got last year at Comic-Con
The Justice League is coming together — literally — in the new trailer for the superhero film, which finds Batman, Wonder Woman, Aquaman, Cyborg and the Flash teaming up for the first time ever on the
Fans can officially start getting excited.
Jamie O'Hara opened up about his current relationship with Bianca Gascoigne  [Wenn] Their very public split was documented after the former couple got together during their time together on
Sen. Cory Booker teased actress Mindy Kaling via Twitter about a joke at his expense on "The Mindy Project" and now it looks like the pair may have dinner.
Sorry fans, Mandy Moore has outright rejected the theory that connects Disney’s 2010 animated feature “Tangled” with its 2013’s animated blockbuster “Frozen.
Actor Harrison Ford said he was distracted and concerned about turbulence from another aircraft last month when he mistakenly landed on a taxiway at a Southern California airport after flying low over
MANILA, Philippines - It’s hard to imagine that a relative newcomer, who has no big-screen credentials under her belt, could instantly join the band of Phili
Film review: Beauty and the Beast
MANILA, Philippines - After more than 50 theater credits at Repertory Philippines and a comeback role of Dr.
MANILA, Philippines - Basil Valdez (photo) celebrates his 40th anniversary with a special one-night-only show titled Basil Valdez @ Sola
MANILA, Philippines - In this age of cheat tracks, lip sync, plus one and the kind used by a big majority of the artists Al Mckay’s Earth, Wind & Fire (E
Side view, either to the right or the left, was the favored photographic pose of Leopoldo Salcedo. And for good reason.
BREAKING WIND NEWS sana nais kong titulo Dito po sa artikulo ng Ang Poet N’yo,
There she is in the San Miguel Beer commercial, turning men’s heads (including Vic Sotto and his son-in-law Marc Pingris, and Marc’s SMB teammate June Ma
Netflix is doubling down on Adam Sandler. The streaming giant has extended its deal with the comedian for four more feature films.
Irish hottie Colin Farrell looks set to take on a Disney classic with talks he is considering being a part of a 'Dumbo' remake.
The actor is currently playing a single father in "Gifted," out April 12.
Disney Junior says it has ordered additional seasons of its animated series "Mickey and the Roadster Racers" and "The Lion Guard."
Martin Clunes has returned to Cornwall film fresh episodes of his ITV dramedy "Doc Martin."
The Tony Award-winner welcomed Sally James last October.
Danger lurks when great symphony orchestras play programs devoted to music of George Gershwin. Not because the ensembles can't dispatch the music brilliantly, but because not all conductors can finess
MTV reality show paid a special tribute to the star this week following the tragic incident. Robert Brian Clark passed away in the motorcycle crash back in December, however, the news of his death
function onPlayerReadyVidible(e){'undefined'!=typeof HPTrack&&HPTrack.Vid.Vidible_track(e)}!function(e,i){if(e.vdb_Player){if('object'==typeof commercial_video){var a='',o='m.fwsitesection='+commer
Another local tradition falls as KIRO and Seafair are ready to ink a contract ending live TV hydroplane coverage and replacing it with a Sunday evening wrap-up. It ends 66 years of live television co
It was a mixed-show but despite the negative reviews, there was a very positive outcome.
ABC News' Diane Macedo reports the buzziest stories of the day in "GMA" Pop News.
ESPN's Tony Reali reports on highlights in the 16-team tournament.

Recent News

Stop judging conferences based on two weeks of March Madness. Just stop it.

Individual teams deserve their spots in the Elite Eight. But that doesn't make the SEC any better now than two weeks ago, nor is the ACC any worse.
Read Full Article

Elite Eight spread picks: Can Kansas keep it going?

The Jayhawks have covered all three of their NCAA tournament games, and it hasn't been all that close.
Read Full Article

Adrian Peterson lashes out at people who say he's asking for too much money

It sure doesn't look like it.
Read Full Article

Clint Dempsey, 'grateful for every game,' moves to cusp of USA soccer history

The veteran star was sidelined for six months by an irregular heartbeat. With a hat trick in a crucial World Cup qualifier on Friday, he has the U.S. national team's career goals record in sight.
Read Full Article

Fantasy Baseball 2017: 10 Injuries To Monitor Entering MLB Season

Ah, fantasy baseball season. The time when you painstakingly assemble a team, only to have one your top players miss... Read More »
Read Full Article

Turkey summons Swiss counsellor over PKK rally in Bern

Turkey's Foreign Ministry summoned Saturday Swiss counsellor in Ankara over terrorist organization PKK sympathizers' rally in Bern
Read Full Article

Cyprus held to disappointing stalemate against Estonia

Cyprus were only able to manage a 0-0 draw against Estonia in their fifth World Cup 2018 qualifier, a result which dispels any realistically hope of qualification. Having only mustered one win in the
Read Full Article

Los Angeles police fatally shoot armed suspect in Boyle Heights

Los Angeles police fatally shot a suspect in Boyle Heights early Saturday, forcing the temporary closure of a Metro Gold Line station, authorities said. Officers were on patrol near 1st and Soto s
Read Full Article

Girls' basketball: Sacramento West Campus wins Division IV title

A dominating rebounding performance, particularly offensive rebounding, helped propel Sacramento West Campus to a 63-55 win over Los Osos in the CIF state championship Division IV girls' final on
Read Full Article

Popular Finance

Los Angeles police fatally shoot armed suspect in Boyle Heights

Los Angeles police fatally shot a suspect in Boyle Heights early Saturday, forcing the temporary closure of a Metro Gold Line station, authorities said. Officers were on patrol near 1st and Soto s
Read Full Article

Girls' basketball: Sacramento West Campus wins Division IV title

A dominating rebounding performance, particularly offensive rebounding, helped propel Sacramento West Campus to a 63-55 win over Los Osos in the CIF state championship Division IV girls' final on
Read Full Article

Low voter turnout could make this California congressional race an election for friends and insiders

Just as the campaign for L.A.’s only open congressional seat this year began to intensify, Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti had a warning. “Trust me, this will be a low-turnout election,” Garcetti
Read Full Article

Villain and heroine: The real-life husband and wife onstage in 'Tales of Hoffmann'

The acclaimed German soprano Diana Damrau met her future husband, French bass-baritone Nicolas Testé, in a Munich church 13 years ago while performing Jean Francaix’s oratorio, “L’Apocalypse Selon
Read Full Article
 

The best electric kettles for coffee, tea, and more

These are the best kettles you can buy.        
Read Full Article
 

Here's how to find great tax breaks you might have missed

We all want to lose less money to taxes. Here's how to hang onto the extra income you've worked hard for.        
Read Full Article
 

Uber execs' trip to karaoke hostess bar raised HR complaint

The 2014 visit resurfaces after exec Emil Michael asked Uber CEO's ex-girlfriend to sanitize description.        
Read Full Article
 

The Salary Chronicles: I Negotiated A $15K Raise As The Only Female VP And Learned A Valuable Lesson

Before leaving on maternity leave this woman was promised a promotion to VP. When she returned she realized that they weren’t going to just hand her a new position, she needed to go ask for it.
Read Full Article

A paperless growth in housing finance

Vastu Housing Finance is trying to leverage technology to distinguish itself in a crowded space
Read Full Article