News Reality

Is the Glycemic Index Reliable and of Any Use?

by www.huffingtonpost.com

The glycemic index has crept upon our food experience. Once a term used by people in white lab coats, reserved to diabetes clinics, it's now part of popular weight-loss programs (South Beach, Zone) and disease prevention plans; the low glycemic index claim is now a selling point plastered on food labels.

Haven't immersed yourself in the glycemic index yet? It's never too late. Or maybe it's still too early. We'll get to that in just a bit, but first, a little introduction.

Glycemic index, explained

The glycemic index, developed initially for the treatment of diabetes, ranks carbohydrate-containing foods based on how they affect blood glucose levels when eaten in isolation. The glycemic index charts were developed by testing people's blood glucose after ingestion of 50 grams (almost 2 ounces) of carbs from different foods.

Carbs that break down quickly, like white bread and potatoes, have a high glycemic index, and those that release sugar into the blood stream more gradually, like fruit, have a low glycemic index. Foods are scored on a scale of 0 to 100.

Since blood glucose fluctuations elicit a cascade of hormonal reactions, which can potentially affect satiety, hunger, blood lipids and inflammation, the glycemic index of a meal sounds like useful thing to control.

We're all different

A new study, led by Nirupa Matthan from Tufts Medical Center, and published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, looked at the blood glucose reaction of 63 healthy people after they were given 50 grams of glucose, either in white bread or in a glucose drink - each experiment was repeated in each volunteer twice.

This is basically a testing of the glycemic index of the bread, and if the glycemic index is a characteristic of the food itself, the results should be similar between the volunteers and between tests.

But that's not what the researchers found. There was a 20 percent change in measured glycemic index of the exact same food between tests in the same individual, and there was 25 percent difference between people.

The glycemic index of the same exact bread ranged from 35 to 103, making it a both low and high on the glycemic index. 

In other words glycemic index wasn't at all consistent, even when the food was eaten in isolation and in a controlled environment.

Is the glycemic index useful?

According to this new study, the glycemic index is not a dependable measurement.

It is also just partial data.

Eating 50 grams of carbs from white bagels is doable. But when it comes to other high glycemic foods, watermelon, for instance (glycemic index - 80) a normal serving will have just a few grams of sugar; you'd have to eat almost 2 pounds of watermelon to load yourself up with 2 ounces of carbs, and therefore, in reality, watermelon's high glycemic index is quite irrelevant. To anticipate glycemic responses you'd also have to familiarize yourself with glycemic load - which also takes into account the amount of carbs consumed.

On top of that, although the type and proportion of sugar or starch in a food affects glycemic index, so do a lot of other factors in the meal--the way the food's been cooked, the presence of fiber, protein, fat, alcohol or acid will all affect the glucose response. Exercising and activity around a meal will affect it, too.

So is it worth bothering with? At this point the evidence of glycemic index centered diets' helpfulness for weight loss or disease prevention is inconsistent (it is helpful for the management of diabetes.)

If you don't have diabetes, it's much easier to follow the well-proven guidelines of limiting added sugar (sugary drinks are especially harmful), eating more plants and whole grains, and minimizing hyper-processed foods.

These simple principles happen to also yield a low glycemic diet - they are a practical shortcut to the same end.

Dr. Ayala

This is a crosspost of my blog, Healthy Food & Healthy Living.

-- This feed and its contents are the property of The Huffington Post, and use is subject to our terms. It may be used for personal consumption, but may not be distributed on a website.


Read Full Article On www.huffingtonpost.com
Latest
NICE is urging medical staff to draw up care plans for terminally ill youngsters, which include their wishes. This could include places to visit, finishing their GCSEs and who be given belongings.
SYDNEY (Reuters) - Australia's center-right Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull on Wednesday ruled out introducing carbon pricing on emissions from the country's power generators after a backlash from wit
A five-year-old child born genetically male will grow up as a sterilised female after a court ruling.
JAKARTA (Reuters) - At least 25 people were killed and dozens were missing after a magnitude 6.4 earthquake hit the northern Indonesian province of Aceh on Wednesday, officials said, collapsing buildi
Health officials sent doctors an alert warning them to continue warning women who are or may become pregnant about travel to areas where the virus is spreading.
Sophie Gajnik began obsessively dieting after she gained five kilograms while at university in Melbourne. Her weight plummeted to just 30kgs and her hair began falling out in clumps.
HealthDay News An experimental drug for infants with the rare, fatal degenerative neuromuscular disease spinal muscular atrophy type 1 shows promise in small clinical trial.
HealthDay News Cardiac arrest patients given epinephrine within five minutes of their heart stopping are more likely to survive than those who don't, according to a study.
JAKARTA (Reuters) - Indonesian search and rescue teams used earth movers to clear rubble after dozens of buildings collapsed in the northern province of Aceh when a 6.4 magnitude earthquake struck on
SEOUL (Reuters) - South Korea's antitrust watchdog said on Wednesday it will file criminal complaints against several executives at Volkswagen AG's South Korean unit and fine the company a record 37.
JAKARTA (Reuters) - Dozens of buildings collapsed on Wednesday in Indonesia's northern province of Aceh, when a 6.4 magnitude earthquake struck in the early hours.
A national audit, led by experts at Oxford University, found a quarter of maternal deaths are linked to cardiac disease - the biggest single cause of death among pregnant women.
More than one in 10 patients in England face long delays for a hospital bed after emergency admission.
Rising numbers of patients are facing long waits for beds in hospitals in England, the BBC finds.
LONDON (Reuters) - Bristol-Myers Squibb's immunotherapy drug Opdivo has been approved in Europe for the treatment of classical Hodgkin lymphoma, a rare blood cancer, the U.S. company said on Wednesday
Research casts doubt on a global mission to use cleaner-burning stoves, to prevent pollution-induced illness in the world's poorest children.
Two-year-olds Eva and Erika Sandoval, of California, share a digestive system, a uterus, a liver, a bladder, and a third leg with a seven-toed foot.
WARNING: GRAPHIC IMAGES. Bulgarian orphan Ryan Morse weighed just eight pounds when he was adopted last year by David and Priscilla Morse of Tennessee.
The strategy would start the process in early January and could defer the effective date for several years, but not all party members were on board.
Skin-to-skin contact between mothers and newborns immediately after birth can be used to promote breastfeeding and may give babies a better start in life, according to a new review of existing evidenc
Two-year-olds Eva and Erika Sandoval, of California, share a digestive system, a uterus, a liver, a bladder, and a third leg with a seven-toed foot.
While most mid-lifers’ hands have been wringing about what menacing changes President-elect Donald Trump has in store for Medicare, Social Security, and their retirement funds, there is a fourt
As a sober mom (8 years in January!) I am freaking serious about stress relief. I have to be, because I never, ever get to opt for the easy relaxation of a glass of wine or other substance to take the
Three years ago, I gave U.S. Travel Association employees who took all of their vacation time a $500 bonus. I'm convinced it was one of the best ideas for increasing productivity and engagement we've
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Repealing Obamacare will be the first order of business in the U.S. Senate in January, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, a Republican, said on Tuesday.
SYDNEY (Reuters) - An earthquake with a magnitude of 6.8 struck 130km southeast of Banda Aceh in northern Sumatra, Indonesia, the United States Geological Survey said.
As usual, this Black Friday was one of the biggest shopping days of the year. Across the United States, stores were thronged with avid shoppers looking for big bargains and holiday deals. REI is a r
The maker of Nutella, the chocolate-hazelnut spread loved by many Americans, wants a smaller serving size to be listed on its nutrition labels. Ferrero, Nutella's parent company, says that a smaller
WASHINGTON/CANNON BALL, N.D. (Reuters) - The company building the Dakota Access Pipeline turned to a federal judge late on Monday for a permit to finish the job after the federal government ruled agai
(Reuters) - An environmental group said on Tuesday it filed a lawsuit against De Beers Canada, accusing the diamond producer of failing to report toxic levels of mercury and methylmercury at its Victo
Scarlett Anne Taylor, five, was sent home from school in Tacoma, WA, with the flu in December 2014. Two days later she was hospitalized with breathing issues. Within hours she was dead.
Steven Reinberg, HealthDay News Cigarettes are one accessory today's California teens are more than willing to forego, a new survey finds.
HealthDay News Preliminary research suggests that a single dose of an experimental gene therapy may help patients with hemophilia B.
Estrogens affect cancer risk, the brain, libido, and other things. Prof Jeffrey Blaustein of the University of Massachusetts Amherst warns too few women understand what this means.

Recent News

Highway robbers dressed as policemen targeted foreign holidaymakers in Madrid

A GANG posing as police officers to rob foreign tourists has been broken up in Madrid, with eight individuals arrested and six vehicles seized.
Read Full Article

Red Wings 4, Jets 3 (SO)

Read Full Article

U-M's Wagner describes furious finish in win over Texas

Michigan's Moe Wagner talks about the 53-50 win over Texas Tuesday at Crisler Center. Video by Mark Snyder/DFP        
Read Full Article

U-M's offense offensive, but they pass test vs. Texas

Free Press sports writer Mark Snyder analyzes the Wolverines' 53-50 win over Texas Tuesday at Crisler Center. Video by Mark Snyder/DFP        
Read Full Article

Michigan 53, Texas 50

Read Full Article

Beilein on Texas victory: You don't see us win like that

Michigan coach John Beilein on the Wolverines' narrow win over Texas, 53-50, Tuesday in Ann Arbor. Video by Mark Snyder/DFP        
Read Full Article

U-M's Duncan Robinson on the maturation of Moe Wagner

Michigan's Duncan Robinson answeres questions after U-M's 53-50 win over Texas Tuesday at Crisler Center. Video by Mark Snyder/DFP        
Read Full Article

Michigan's Moritz Wagner shines, saves win over Texas with defense

German big man scores 15 points, comes up with big block late to seal victory        
Read Full Article

House GOP eyes food stamp overhaul, possible requirements

WASHINGTON - House Republicans are laying the groundwork for a fresh effort to overhaul the nation's food stamp program during Donald Trump's presidency, with the possibility of new work and eligibili
Read Full Article

Popular Finance

 

Asian stocks higher on record Dow, telecom news

Investors cheered by gains on Wall Street.        
Read Full Article

Industry capacity may hit 150 MT in couple of years: Steel Secy

Government extended minimum import price (MIP) on 19 products for two months to protect domestic steel industry from below-cost imports. Steel Secretary Aruna Sharma believes that steel capacity wi
Read Full Article

RBI may cut rate by 50 bps; liquidity, inflation call eyed: Pros

The Reserve Bank of India will hold its bi-monthly policy meet today. Experts expect 25 basis point (bps) cut. But, probability of a 50 bps cut cannot be ruled out, says Vivek Rajpal, Rate strategis
Read Full Article

Iran-Japan Business Forum 2016 kicks off in Tokyo

Tokyo, Dec 7, IRNA – The first conference on Iran-Japan trade started in the presence of Iran's Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif and senior Japanese economic officials here on Wednesday morn
Read Full Article

Official: Iran, Japan need to promote decades-old trade ties

Tokyo, Dec 7, IRNA – Chairman of Iran’s Chamber of Commerce, Industries, Mines and Agriculture Gholamhossein Shafei said Iran and Japan need to promote their 87-year-old commercial relations.
Read Full Article

BRIEF-Symrise extends contract of CEO Bertram until 2022

* Symrise AG says CEO contract of Heinz-Juergen Bertram extended ahead of schedule until 2022 Source text for Eikon: Further company coverage:
Read Full Article

BRIEF-Tsuchiya Holdings to repurchase up to 600,000 shares at up to 100 mln yen

* Says it to repurchase up to 600,000 shares of its common stock, representing a 2.35 percent stake
Read Full Article

BRIEF-Sberbank 11-month net profit to RAS rises to RUB 483.2 bln

* 11-month net profit to Russian Accounting Standards (RAS) of 483.2 billion roubles ($7.56 billion) versus 202.4 billion roubles
Read Full Article

BRIEF-Debt collection firm Arrow Global appoints former Virgin Money CFO as CEO

* Lee Rochford, formerly CFO of Virgin Money will replace Tom as group CEO and board director from 3 January 2017. Source text for Eikon: Further company coverage:
Read Full Article