News Reality

Is the Glycemic Index Reliable and of Any Use?

by www.huffingtonpost.com

The glycemic index has crept upon our food experience. Once a term used by people in white lab coats, reserved to diabetes clinics, it's now part of popular weight-loss programs (South Beach, Zone) and disease prevention plans; the low glycemic index claim is now a selling point plastered on food labels.

Haven't immersed yourself in the glycemic index yet? It's never too late. Or maybe it's still too early. We'll get to that in just a bit, but first, a little introduction.

Glycemic index, explained

The glycemic index, developed initially for the treatment of diabetes, ranks carbohydrate-containing foods based on how they affect blood glucose levels when eaten in isolation. The glycemic index charts were developed by testing people's blood glucose after ingestion of 50 grams (almost 2 ounces) of carbs from different foods.

Carbs that break down quickly, like white bread and potatoes, have a high glycemic index, and those that release sugar into the blood stream more gradually, like fruit, have a low glycemic index. Foods are scored on a scale of 0 to 100.

Since blood glucose fluctuations elicit a cascade of hormonal reactions, which can potentially affect satiety, hunger, blood lipids and inflammation, the glycemic index of a meal sounds like useful thing to control.

We're all different

A new study, led by Nirupa Matthan from Tufts Medical Center, and published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, looked at the blood glucose reaction of 63 healthy people after they were given 50 grams of glucose, either in white bread or in a glucose drink - each experiment was repeated in each volunteer twice.

This is basically a testing of the glycemic index of the bread, and if the glycemic index is a characteristic of the food itself, the results should be similar between the volunteers and between tests.

But that's not what the researchers found. There was a 20 percent change in measured glycemic index of the exact same food between tests in the same individual, and there was 25 percent difference between people.

The glycemic index of the same exact bread ranged from 35 to 103, making it a both low and high on the glycemic index. 

In other words glycemic index wasn't at all consistent, even when the food was eaten in isolation and in a controlled environment.

Is the glycemic index useful?

According to this new study, the glycemic index is not a dependable measurement.

It is also just partial data.

Eating 50 grams of carbs from white bagels is doable. But when it comes to other high glycemic foods, watermelon, for instance (glycemic index - 80) a normal serving will have just a few grams of sugar; you'd have to eat almost 2 pounds of watermelon to load yourself up with 2 ounces of carbs, and therefore, in reality, watermelon's high glycemic index is quite irrelevant. To anticipate glycemic responses you'd also have to familiarize yourself with glycemic load - which also takes into account the amount of carbs consumed.

On top of that, although the type and proportion of sugar or starch in a food affects glycemic index, so do a lot of other factors in the meal--the way the food's been cooked, the presence of fiber, protein, fat, alcohol or acid will all affect the glucose response. Exercising and activity around a meal will affect it, too.

So is it worth bothering with? At this point the evidence of glycemic index centered diets' helpfulness for weight loss or disease prevention is inconsistent (it is helpful for the management of diabetes.)

If you don't have diabetes, it's much easier to follow the well-proven guidelines of limiting added sugar (sugary drinks are especially harmful), eating more plants and whole grains, and minimizing hyper-processed foods.

These simple principles happen to also yield a low glycemic diet - they are a practical shortcut to the same end.

Dr. Ayala

This is a crosspost of my blog, Healthy Food & Healthy Living.

-- This feed and its contents are the property of The Huffington Post, and use is subject to our terms. It may be used for personal consumption, but may not be distributed on a website.


Read Full Article On www.huffingtonpost.com
Latest
COX'S BAZAR, Bangladesh (Reuters) - Bangladesh has evacuated at least 350,000 people as a cyclone lashed coastal areas on Tuesday, officials said, causing havoc in refugee camps set up for Rohingya Mu
SEOUL (Reuters) - South Korea will halt operations at eight of the country's older coal-fired power plants for a month in June as part of measures to tackle air pollution, the energy ministry said on
If drug users overdose on substances containing fentanyl or other opioids like heroin, methadone and morphine, naloxone can reverse overdose effects. The medication does not work for other drugs
Bills seeking to rein in the cost of prescription drugs include proposals to speed approval of generic drugs and allow the importing of cheaper drugs.
A civil war has broken out among the most powerful players in the industry, which is scrambling in the face of public anger and legislative efforts to reduce costs.
The effort follows through on the presidentís pledge to roll back a requirement that many religious employers include contraception coverage in health insurance.
When told the bright red rash on his leg might be sepsis or even a flesh-eating bug, Matt Hazledine was shocked.
Studying rats, researchers in France found that those who were raised on a diet high in processed foods experienced a far greater rush of pleasure from junk food as adults.
If you treat the problem yourself, the difficulty is choosing the most effective product available over the counter.
An analysis published in The Journal of Pediatrics considers figures from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administrationís Fatal Analysis Reporting System.
Elizabeth, 28, from Brighton, has suffered from worsening anxiety for several years. It is affecting her ability to meet new people but she is reluctant to try medication to treat it.
Fresh from her role as DCI Roz Huntley in Line Of Duty, Thandie Newton recently swept on to the red carpet in a strapless gown that showed off her toned upper body and shoulders.
The idea of growing a colony of worms inside you may sound unappetising, but for thousands of people, it becomes an annual, or even weekly task they perform.
Scientists are finding more and more health benefits to having a quick blast of cold water, including boosting your immune system and easing low mood.
Scientists at The Scripps Research Institute in the US modified the drug so it works in three separate ways on bacteria, making it much harder for them to develop resistance.
Air pollution has become a major health problem in Britain, claiming more lives here than in most Western European countries, an alarming UN report revealed last week.
This article uses the breaking news that golfer Tiger Woods was arrested for impaired driving (DUI) to explore the history of drunk driving, and why it remains a stubbornly difficult problem in Americ
The latest quarterly reshuffle of the FTSE 100, the UKís leading blue-chip share index, takes place this week. Candidates to fall out of Britainís benchmark index with the highest market capitalizatio
Doctors often donít ask about sexual orientation and gender identity because they donít want to make patients uncomfortable. But a new study suggests that concern may be unfounded.
Patients with strep infections were far more likely to suffer damaged heart valves if they had a certain mutation, researchers reported.
A small study of football players found their verbal abilities declined over an eight-year period, compared with those of team coaches and executives.
Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has juggling act as he tries to write a Republican health care bill that can pass the Senate
Injury rates among elite young female athletes may be higher than whatís been reported, new data suggest.
While enjoying a glass of wine, many don't realize they are consuming grams of sugar. Red is the best option for dieters while dessert wines should be avoided with nearly two teaspoons of sugar.
In a major trial, rVSV-ZEBOV caused mild side effects including headache, fatigue and muscle pain, but those side effects don't appear to be long term.
Young onset type 2 diabetes patients have an increased risk of developing diabetic retinopathy at an earlier stage and at a greater frequency, according to researchers.
Semi-transparent perovskite solar cells have been developed that could be great candidates for solar windows, say researchers.
A mobile biofeedback device has been developed for footstrike pattern modification for injury prevention and rehabilitation in runners.
A possible genetic mechanism underlying the evolution of birds has been discovered by scientists. Studies of dinosaur fossils that show bird-like traits, such as feathers, light bones, air sacs and th
New research challenges established medical practice that all heart attack patients should be on beta blockers.
Back pain affects most Canadians. Investigative journalist and back pain sufferer Cathryn Jakobson Ramin says it's time to rethink treatment.
Leeds University researchers found no difference in death rates between patients given beta-blockers and those who weren't in the 12 months after they suffered a heart attack.
HIV is notorious for lying dormant in immune cells in a way that even the most developed and expensive methods could not spot.
The quest to develop a cure for HIV has long been plagued by a seemingly simple question: how do doctors determine if someone is cured? The virus has a knack for lying dormant in immune cells at level

Recent News

Kerr not well yet, but hasn't ruled himself out for Game 1

Read Full Article

Jessica Chastain Calls Out Cannes Films For Dismal Portrayal Of Women Characters

function onPlayerReadyVidible(e){'undefined'!=typeof HPTrack&&HPTrack.Vid.Vidible_track(e)}!function(e,i){if(e.vdb_Player){if('object'==typeof commercial_video){var a='',o='m.fwsitesection='+commer
Read Full Article

What's on TV? Detroit sports listings for May 30

Sporting events you can check out on your couch on May 30        
Read Full Article

Tigers minors: Mud Hens shut out Scranton/WB; Erie, ĎCaps lose

In the fifth, Bryan Holaday hit a solo home run, while Michael Almanzar hit a three-run home run in the eighth.        
Read Full Article

Cyclone Mora hits Bangladesh, destroys Myanmar refugee camps

Cyclone Mora struck the island of Saint Martin and Teknaf in the coastal district of Cox's Bazar
Read Full Article

Aurora Australis: Colourful show hits Australia and New Zealand

Onlookers are treated to a spectacular display as the Southern Lights hit Australia and New Zealand.
Read Full Article

Sensex back in green, Nifty regains 8,600; Smallcap index underpeforms

ICICI Bank, Cipla and Lupin were the best-performers on Sensex and added up to 2% on the BSE
Read Full Article

L&T hits 21-month high post Q4 results, 1:2 bonus share plan

The stock hit high of Rs 1,834, up 2.6% on BSE, its highest level since August 10, 2015.
Read Full Article

Jubilant FoodWorks tanks 13% after over 75% fall in Q4 net profit

During the quarter, it also reported exceptional cost of Rs 12.17 cr related to one time separation
Read Full Article

Popular Finance

Angels' Albert Pujols is two home runs away from 600 club

While the Angels took their first wobbly steps into an immediate future without star center fielder Mike Trout, slugger Albert Pujols moved another step closer to history Monday night. Pujols drov
Read Full Article

Trump's day in tweets: Monday, May 29

Read Full Article

This machine can knit a custom blazer in 90 minutes ó and may herald a clothing revolution

With its tidy racks of dress shirts, trousers and sweaters, the Ministry of Supply shop on Bostonís Newbury Street looks, in many ways, similar to other clothing stores. That is, except for the 10
Read Full Article

Three killed in head-on collision between passenger car and big rig near Desert Center

Three people were killed Monday in a head-on collision between a passenger car and a big rig about 19 miles north of Desert Center in Riverside County, authorities said. A fourth person was extric
Read Full Article

Pittsburgh Penguins hold off late Nashville Predators rally to win Stanley Cup Final opener 5-3

Awakening from a slumber after going 37 minutes without taking a shot on goal, the Pittsburgh Penguins proved that they hadnít forgotten how to shoot and score, after all. Rookie Jake Guentzel bro
Read Full Article

Deadly holiday weekend on roaring Kern River: 3 dead, 24 rescued

Two dead and more rescued from roaring Kern River this weekend.
Read Full Article

Enduring Heroes Memorial pays tribute to war dead from Pasadena and neighboring cities

Amid the Memorial Day parades and services held throughout the Southland on Monday, the families of a group of fallen soldiers and Marines gathered in a Pasadena park for a long-awaited tribute to
Read Full Article

Mississippi's Braden Thornberry shoots a final-round 71 to become NCAA men's golf champion

One big swing gave Mississippi sophomore Braden Thornberry control, and he never let go until he was the NCAA men's golf champion. Thornberry capped off a big year Monday when he closed with a on
Read Full Article

Woman on a rock-climbing outing is rescued after trying to help a dog and falling 30 feet

A Northern California woman on a rock-climbing outing lost her footing while helping a dog and tumbled 30 feet before she was rescued by helicopter. The Sacramento Bee reports that Michelle Powell
Read Full Article