News Reality

Is the Glycemic Index Reliable and of Any Use?


The glycemic index has crept upon our food experience. Once a term used by people in white lab coats, reserved to diabetes clinics, it's now part of popular weight-loss programs (South Beach, Zone) and disease prevention plans; the low glycemic index claim is now a selling point plastered on food labels.

Haven't immersed yourself in the glycemic index yet? It's never too late. Or maybe it's still too early. We'll get to that in just a bit, but first, a little introduction.

Glycemic index, explained

The glycemic index, developed initially for the treatment of diabetes, ranks carbohydrate-containing foods based on how they affect blood glucose levels when eaten in isolation. The glycemic index charts were developed by testing people's blood glucose after ingestion of 50 grams (almost 2 ounces) of carbs from different foods.

Carbs that break down quickly, like white bread and potatoes, have a high glycemic index, and those that release sugar into the blood stream more gradually, like fruit, have a low glycemic index. Foods are scored on a scale of 0 to 100.

Since blood glucose fluctuations elicit a cascade of hormonal reactions, which can potentially affect satiety, hunger, blood lipids and inflammation, the glycemic index of a meal sounds like useful thing to control.

We're all different

A new study, led by Nirupa Matthan from Tufts Medical Center, and published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, looked at the blood glucose reaction of 63 healthy people after they were given 50 grams of glucose, either in white bread or in a glucose drink - each experiment was repeated in each volunteer twice.

This is basically a testing of the glycemic index of the bread, and if the glycemic index is a characteristic of the food itself, the results should be similar between the volunteers and between tests.

But that's not what the researchers found. There was a 20 percent change in measured glycemic index of the exact same food between tests in the same individual, and there was 25 percent difference between people.

The glycemic index of the same exact bread ranged from 35 to 103, making it a both low and high on the glycemic index. 

In other words glycemic index wasn't at all consistent, even when the food was eaten in isolation and in a controlled environment.

Is the glycemic index useful?

According to this new study, the glycemic index is not a dependable measurement.

It is also just partial data.

Eating 50 grams of carbs from white bagels is doable. But when it comes to other high glycemic foods, watermelon, for instance (glycemic index - 80) a normal serving will have just a few grams of sugar; you'd have to eat almost 2 pounds of watermelon to load yourself up with 2 ounces of carbs, and therefore, in reality, watermelon's high glycemic index is quite irrelevant. To anticipate glycemic responses you'd also have to familiarize yourself with glycemic load - which also takes into account the amount of carbs consumed.

On top of that, although the type and proportion of sugar or starch in a food affects glycemic index, so do a lot of other factors in the meal--the way the food's been cooked, the presence of fiber, protein, fat, alcohol or acid will all affect the glucose response. Exercising and activity around a meal will affect it, too.

So is it worth bothering with? At this point the evidence of glycemic index centered diets' helpfulness for weight loss or disease prevention is inconsistent (it is helpful for the management of diabetes.)

If you don't have diabetes, it's much easier to follow the well-proven guidelines of limiting added sugar (sugary drinks are especially harmful), eating more plants and whole grains, and minimizing hyper-processed foods.

These simple principles happen to also yield a low glycemic diet - they are a practical shortcut to the same end.

Dr. Ayala

This is a crosspost of my blog, Healthy Food & Healthy Living.

-- This feed and its contents are the property of The Huffington Post, and use is subject to our terms. It may be used for personal consumption, but may not be distributed on a website.

Read Full Article On
Doctors' leaders are calling for the urgent introduction of a 24-hour helpline for prescription drug dependence.
What is it like being a midwife specialising in baby deaths?
Hospital visits by Jehovah's Witness elders, aimed at defending the right of members to refuse blood transfusions, are under scrutiny following the d
As the 12th national prescription drug take-back day ended at 2 pm today, one new approach to fight opiate diversion—the misuse of prescription opiates--is whether offering economic incentives such as
As the 12th national prescription drug take-back day ended at 2 pm today, one new approach to fight opiate diversion—the misuse of prescription opiates--is whether offering economic incentives such as
A spotlight has been put on Indigenous health care — especially mental health supports — following the suicides of four girls in northern Saskatchewa
Dr. M-J Milloy, a research scientist with the British Columbia Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS, says harm reduction efforts could be an important f
SYDNEY (Reuters) - An Australia court overturned on Saturday government approval of a A$130 million fuel depot and port at Port Melville, off the country’s north coast, handing a major victory to envi
If Ottawa lets Big Tobacco into the e-cigarette business it would be handing the industry the chance to hook teenagers on nicotine and turn them into
Proponents say treatment helps with several ailments, but it is not without controversy             
Melanie Mitchell, manager of Boost Cryospa, gives Marion Hackett a Cryofacial. The ice cold vapor helps to produce collagen in the skin.             
Hannah Humphrey, 25, from Ipswich,dropped from a size 18 to a size eight in just 18 months, which triggered her gallstones. An operation to remove them also found a cancerous tumour.
Have you heard of the CNN effect? There is also a “fake ID effect:” This is when a fake piece of identification facilitates later harms. Researchers already know that underage college students who obt
Soylent meal replacement bars are being recalled after reports of illness, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency said Friday.
ATCHISON, Kansas (Reuters) - More than 100 people were treated for respiratory problems after a chemical spill at an MGP Ingredients Inc facility on Friday generated a chemical cloud over the northeas
Monkeys observed by a team at UC Davis had higher levels of inflammation if they felt unsure about whether they were a leader or a follower in their group.
HealthDay News A growing number of American children with headaches are being seen at pediatric emergency departments and admitted to the hospital, researchers report.
We all like to think of ourselves as the woman warrior, the indomitable female the can-do girl who lives every moment with intensity and attention. But, alas, we are human and we have our down days an
You'll find my favorite Halloween decoration at the front desk of my dental practice: a bowl of candy labeled "free cavities." (Yes, I know, dentists are hilarious!) This weekend, children will dre
Students are pouring hundreds of tons of plain milk into the garbage in Los Angeles schools each week. Maybe that's because more than 88 percent of Los Angeles Unified School District students are p
Here's a fact you can impress your friends with -- every 30 minutes your kidneys filter all the blood in your body eliminating waste and excess fluid. Pretty amazing isn't it. Yet, how many of us re
(Reuters) - Former Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders, in an opinion editorial published in the Los Angeles Times, on Friday urged Californians to approve a November ballot measure aimed
At the third and final debate last Wednesday, GOP presidential candidate Donald Trump drew a lot of criticism for his medically inaccurate and emotionally charged description of late-term abortio
OTTAWA (Reuters) - Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is usually greeted by cheering crowds when he goes out in public but received a less pleasant welcome in Hamilton on Friday - a handful of pum
(Reuters Health) - Heart attack survivors who participate in cardiac rehabilitation programs may survive longer, but feel no healthier, than they would without this follow-up care, a U.S. study sugges
Umpire Rock, also known as Rat Rock, has been a climbing oasis for children, and adults, of all ages for decades.
Remember that scene in “When Harry Met Sally” when Sally does her best “fake orgasm” impression in Katz’s Deli?  Well, the WatchCut Video above is
(Reuters) - A Sunoco Logistics Partners LP pipeline spilled about 1,300 barrels of gasoline into the Susquehanna River in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, on Friday, according to local media.
Couples often ask for advice about for how they can improve their communication. "If we could just find better ways to communicate with each other," they say, "we would have a much better relationship
I have previously expressed my appreciation of the JAMA 1993 paper "Actual Causes of Death in the US", written by Mike McGinnis and Bill Foege. The paper is central in the course that I that I am now
Researchers at the University of British Columbia found that people chose smaller portions of cake when they were asked to vividly imagine the taste, smell, and texture of desserts.
45 minutes into a killer bootcamp workout, sweat dripped from my forehead, my muscles ached. With the fervor of a nervous first time city council candidate addressing a room of two dozen senior cit
HealthDay News Traffic crash death rates for American children vary widely among states, and safety regulations are a major reason why, a new study suggests.
A special thanks to Miranda Ebraheim for assisting in this article. Rat-bite fever is an illness caused from bacteria that is transmitted by rodents. The condition goes by many names but it is ty

Recent News

Ed Balls's 'dodgy' Strictly Come Dancing lift

Ed Balls is bottom of the Strictly Come Dancing leaderboard after his Saturday night routine went wrong.
Read Full Article

Leslie Jones hits out at hackers and trolls in SNL sketch

US comedian and Ghostbusters actress Leslie Jones takes aim at the hackers who published nude photos of her and private details online.
Read Full Article

Turkey Reports More Than 35 000 in Detention after Coup Attempt

There are more than 35 000 people in detention in Turkey more than three months after this year's attempted coup, says Justice Minister Bekir Bozda?, noting that a further 4,000 remain under investiga
Read Full Article

Afghanistan's Opium Production Rises Drastically - UN Report

Afghanistan's opium production has risen sharply this year in comparison to last, according to an executive summary of the country's official opium survey released Sunday. Opium production in the war-
Read Full Article

Qatar Announces 'Work-Related' Death at WCup Stadium Site

Organizers of the 2022 World Cup in Qatar say a worker has died in a "work-related" incident at a stadium building site
Read Full Article

Saudi Arabian minister invites Novak to GCC oil ministers meeting

Saudi Arabia’s Minister of Energy, Industry and Mineral Resources Khalid Al-Falih invited Russia’s Minister of Energy Alexander Novak to participate in a meeting of the Gulf Cooperation Council petrol
Read Full Article

Taylor Swift Is Officially Out of the Woods: Inside Her Unforgettable--and Only--Show of 2016

In case you were worried that Taylor Swift might not bounce back so easily from any personal drama that had occurred over the summer... Ha, you're good to quit thinking such nonsense...
Read Full Article

Then a 'great woman', now 'nasty': Donald Trump's changing views on Hillary Clinton

Trump has called his rival 'Crooked Hillary' throughout the campaign and also made many personal attacks
Read Full Article

US condemns use of chemical weapons by Assad's regime

Of the nine alleged chemical attacks, the UN-led joint investigative mechanism has attributed three to the Syrian government and one to the ISIS
Read Full Article

Popular Finance


Canada's Fortis makes inroads into U.S. market

Fortis began trading on the NYSE after completing its acquisition of ITC Holdings        
Read Full Article

What's this? We can't fight smog and climate change at the same time?

Tapping methane produced from decaying garbage in landfills to generate electricity was among California’s earliest experiments in renewable energy. But in order to comply with a new regional rule
Read Full Article

Campaign 2016 updates: Donald Trump focuses on Florida, where he will hold several rallies over next few days

Campaign 2016 updates: Donald Trump focuses on Florida, where he will hold several rallies over next few days Oct. 23, 2016, 3:20 a.m. Hillary Clinton is in North Carolina, while Donald Trump hits
Read Full Article

Rigged election? Trump is just hanging himself out to dry

Say what you will about Donald Trump, he’s already kept one campaign promise: “I’ll keep you in suspense.” That’s what Trump said last week when debate moderator Chris Wallace asked if he would pr
Read Full Article

If you want to influence people don't try to persuade them. Use 'pre-suasion' instead.

Today and every day we are the targets of salespeople, marketers, advertisers, fundraisers and (heaven knows) politicians trying to persuade us to buy something, do something or think a certain wa
Read Full Article

1 LAPD officer, 2 fatal shootings days apart. How quickly should officers who kill return to work?

This summer, for the first time in his nearly five years as a Los Angeles police officer, Eden Medina shot someone. Police say Medina opened fire July 28 as Omar Gonzalez fought with officers afte
Read Full Article

Italy recovers 14 dead in 2 days on smugglers' boats

Italian officials say that 14 bodies have been recovered in a two-day period on smugglers' boats packed with migrants making the perilous journey across the Mediterranean.  The Italian Coast Guard
Read Full Article

SUNDAY NEWSPAPER SHARE TIPS: Revolution Bars, Snapchat and IAG

This week, Midas looks into drinks company Revolution Bars Group. Meanwhile, the Sunday Telegraph looks at online social company Snapchat and the Sunday Times takes a look at IAG.
Read Full Article

Low rates and rising inflation mean more misery for savers

The Mail on Sunday proposes a three-point cash savers’ ‘rescue’ plan that Philip Hammond should implement with his Autumn Statement on November 23.
Read Full Article