News Reality

Berggruen Prize Winner, Charles Taylor, Is a Transformational Teacher


The university teacher, we are told, may soon be obsolete. There’s no point lecturing to a large group of students if the same material can be communicated via video. That may be true. But Charles Taylor ? the winner of this year’s Berggruen Prize in Philosophy ? reminds us that personal experience with teachers can have transformational effects on the lives of young students.

Charles Taylor is famous not just for his writings, but also for his role as teacher and mentor of globally influential public intellectuals like Michael Sandel.

Regrettably, I was never personally supervised by Charles Taylor. As an undergrad in the 1980s, I majored in psychology at McGill University in Montreal. Psychology seemed like a natural choice because I thought the field would unlock the keys of human nature. My expectations were soon dashed. Students spent their time on experiments with rats in mazes on the grounds their behavior could shed scientific light on the behavior of humans. We did not read Sigmund Freud or Carl Jung because their theories did not match the standards of contemporary science. And I learned nothing about how people think and act in the rest of the world. The field has made great progress since then ? especially in social and cross-cultural psychology ? but I knew it wasn’t for me.

Taylor reminds us that personal experience with teachers can have transformational effects on the lives of young students.

In my final undergraduate year, I happened to take a class on Plato and Aristotle taught by Charles Taylor. He had been recommended by one of my professors but I knew nothing else about him. It was a transformational experience.

By means of close readings of Plato’s “Republic” and Aristotle’s “Politics,” Taylor posed all the questions that seemed to matter (to me): Which forms of political community are realistic and desirable? Which values matter, and why? Are we purely selfish human beings, or can morality shape the way we lead our lives? Is there one form of justice, or do forms of justice vary from community to community? How do we engage with communities that prioritize different values? What is the relation between our actual preferences and ideas about how we ought to lead our lives?

Far from answering the questions, he invited students to think about better and worse answers. And he switched to beautiful and eloquent French in response to questions by Francophone students: at the time, the only professor I knew who paid more than lip service to the bilingualism of our home city. 

Which values matter, and why?

It was a large class ? about 60 students, if I recall correctly. Professor Taylor seemed kind and approachable, but I did not dare talk to him at the time (to this day, I’m still a bit nervous when I talk to him, but it’s nothing a glass of wine can’t cure). But I was inspired by his example, and I chose to pursue studies in political theory at Oxford, where he had also done graduate work and served as professor before returning to McGill. Maybe the language of “choice” is not appropriate: I was so enraptured by Taylor the teacher that it seemed like the only natural and right thing to do. Almost like falling in love: but in an intellectual sense.

At Oxford, I met two of Taylor’s students from McGill ? Daniel Weinstock and Gopal Sreenivasan ? who were similarly inspired by him (they are now distinguished philosophers at McGill and Duke). As for myself, I decided to write a thesis on communitarianism, with Taylor’s work front and center. Taylor’s writings, which I had not read as an undergraduate, spoke to me directly, not just by the force of the argumentation, but because I had memories of Taylor the teacher.

Transformational experiences are more likely in small settings, with teachers who engage with students in seminar-like discussions.

It’s worth asking if such transformational experiences can take place by watching videos or TED talks of great intellectuals. I suspect not. For one thing, transformational experiences are more likely in small settings, with teachers who engage with students in seminar-like discussions. In my case, my professional “choice” was reinforced by one year I spent at McGill as a visiting graduate student. I was part of an informal reading group led by Taylor on Heidegger’s “Being and Time,” and I’ve since used this model with my own graduate students. 

Still, I made my “choice” because I was inspired by Taylor in a large classroom setting, without any personal experience talking to my teacher. Perhaps there’s something about personal exposure to great and inspiring minds that can touch the soul. And that can happen even without extensive personal interaction with the teacher. However much I’ve become addicted to the internet since those days, I still hope young students can have opportunities for similar transformational experiences in the future.

-- This feed and its contents are the property of The Huffington Post, and use is subject to our terms. It may be used for personal consumption, but may not be distributed on a website.

Read Full Article On
Sometimes your co-workers are just like you and other times they just so happen to be huge stars who turned down the spotlight for a normal job. Although Hollywood is filled with glitz, glamour and t
U.S. President Donald Trump reportedly yelled at Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas during their meeting in Bethlehem last week, accusing Abbas of lying, Israeli television reported Sunday
Our daily pick of the best free software – a free indie game that delivers vital lessons in road safety and color-matching.
The Trump administration Sunday hit back at allegations of improper contacts between presidential son-in-law and top adviser Jared Kushner and Russian officials, saying such contacts are normal, as D
While there are still a few weeks left until the beginning of summer, Memorial Day is almost here and that means the unofficial start of season is right around the corner. Whether you’re heading to t
It’s not really a Marvel movie without a Stan Lee cameo, and apparently that rule goes for theme park rides too. The Marvel Comics legend is a part of the new Guardians of the Galaxy - Mission: Break
Move may lead to dispute with exporting nations at the WTO
In 1905, an Ohio farmer survived a railroad accident that cost him both of his legs. Two years later, he founded the Ohio Willow Wood company, using the namesake timber to hand-carve prosthetic limbs
The Centre has come up with a novel initiative to get people’s queries on the proposed GST system addressed in a timely manner. A new Twitter handle — @askGST_GOI — has been set up for this purpose.
This question originally appeared on Quora. Answer by Dave Consiglio. No. Capitalism should change. Capitalism works reasonably well as an economic system - provided that human beings are required to
U.S. President Donald Trump celebrated his first diplomatic trip abroad Sunday by ramping up complaints against the news media and decrying the lack of post-election coverage of the Montana congressi
Millions of girls and women are displaced and on the move right now globally – and the Trump administration’s proposed drastic cuts to humanitarian aid will have a major impact on these girls’ and wo
This article originally appeared on the Motley Fool. Though you'd think the bubble would've burst by now, college costs are still on the rise, and as a result, student debt is at an all-time high. Am
Snap has picked up a small drone business, which means we could all soon be Snapchatting from the air.
Kaitlin Doubleday is back on a musical drama, but it’s not “Empire.” Her character Rhonda was killed off the hip-hop drama last year, so now the actress is headed to a different TV show about the mus
The United States didn't successfully get a spacecraft to Mars until 1971 after years of failed attempts and months after Russia (then the USSR) had successfully landed a craft on the red planet. The
Mutants like the X-Men might be much more likely to emerge in a human society living on another planet than here are on Earth, because radiation can really mess with evolution.
The frog (Hyalinobatrachium yaku), discovered in the Amazonian lowlands of Ecuador has unique physical and behavioural traits.
YouTube star and prankster Roman Atwood is turning 34, and the father of two has a lot to celebrate this year. Not only did he surpass 10 million subscribers on his YouTube Channel in 2016, but he ha
“Game of Thrones” fans got their first glimpse of what’s to come in Season 7 of the HBO original series on Wednesday, after an action-packed trailer teasing a “Great War” ahead was released. Now, vie
The research team sampled sediment and rocks from the tectonic plate that feeds the Sumatra subduction zone for the first time.
An indigenous rocket as heavy as 200 full-grown Asian elephants could well be the one taking "Indians into space from Indian soil" as the country inches closer to joining the big boy#39;s space club
This question originally appeared on Quora. Answer by Ray Schilling. Blood has many functions.
A new survey found 67 percent of medical device manufacturers and 56 percent of healthcare delivery organizations (HDOs) believe their devices are likely to be the target of a cyberattack within the
Memorial Day is marked this year on May 29 to remember heroic work of all the soldiers who sacrificed their lives for the nation. On this day, people across the nation pay tribute to service members
More than a third of departures are cancelled, as disruption caused by an IT crash enters a second day.
LONDON (Reuters) - Britain is looking at range of options to put pressure on internet companies to do more to take down extremist material, Security Minister Ben Wallace said on Sunday.
Opinion: H-1B visas are vital to US scientific advancement. The post Cutting H-1B Visas Endangers Scientific Progress For Everyone appeared first on WIRED.
Mark Zuckerberg wants Facebook to build a global community. Easier said than done. The post The Community Zuck Longs to Build Remains a Distant Dream appeared first on WIRED.
Despite being a gamble for the consumer, crowdfunding is the only way a small group of people can turn their idea into a sustainable company. The post Why You Should Keep Funding Kickstarter Projects
The web's favorite way to say how you feel just turned 30. Yep, it turns out the GIF is a millennial, too. The post The GIF Turns 30: How an Ancient Format Changed the Internet appeared first on WIRE

Recent News

Mississippi shooting sparked by domestic dispute leaves 8 dead, including 2 boys

Authorities in Mississippi say a suspect is in custody after eight people were killed in a series of shootings, including a sheriff's deputy.
Read Full Article

Trump slams media reports of Kushner's Russia contacts as 'fabricated lies'

Congressional Democrats on Sunday demanded to hear directly from top White House adviser Jared Kushner over allegations of proposed secret back-chann
Read Full Article

If Trump pulls out of climate deal, US could join Syria and Nicaragua as nonparticipants

Trump said in a tweet that he would make his ‘‘final decision’’ this week.
Read Full Article

Crash knocks pole-sitter Scott Dixon out of Indy 500

Pole-sitter Scott Dixon went airborne in Sunday's Indianapolis 500, sending his car into the inside fence and retaining wall in Turn 2 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway.
Read Full Article

New England Patriots QB Tom Brady delivers video message at funeral of Navy SEAL

New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady delivered a video message to the family of a Navy SEAL killed recently in action.
Read Full Article

NFC OTA Surprises: Half are wide receivers

Off-season practices are not where offensive linemen establish themselves. OTAs (organized team activities) and minicamps are made to order for "skill-position" players.
Read Full Article

AFC OTA Surprises: Pass-catchers dominate

Off-season practices are not where offensive linemen establish themselves. OTAs (organized team activities) and minicamps are made to order for "skill-position" players.
Read Full Article

Cleveland Indians send struggling Danny Salazar to bullpen

The Cleveland Indians announced Sunday that struggling right-handed starter Danny Salazar will be sent to bullpen to work on his throwing routine and regain his confidence.
Read Full Article

STC fifth grader makes world golf

CEBUANA junior golfer Grace Pauline Quintanilla clinched a slot to the US Kids Golf World Championship after topping the Philippine International qualifier at the Orchard Golf and Country Club in Cavi
Read Full Article

Popular Finance

Trump blasts media over 'poorly covered' Montana election

Read Full Article

President Trump calls first overseas trip 'a great success' despite mixed reviews

Read Full Article

Trump accuses media of publishing 'lies' as he returns home to Kushner-Russia back channel reports

Read Full Article

Trump tweets that British Prime Minister Theresa May was 'very angry' over Manchester leaks

Read Full Article

A 'Monumental' exhibit of Alexander Calder's works at Denver Botanic Gardens

"Calder: Monumental" is on display at the gardens' York Street location and will not travel, making the exhibition unique.
Read Full Article

U.S. coach Bruce Arena calls up European-heavy roster for World Cup qualifiers

National team coach Bruce Arena has chosen a veteran 27-man roster for next month’s World Cup soccer qualifiers with Trinidad and Tobago as well as Mexico, with nine players coming off European cl
Read Full Article

Dodgers' Brandon McCarthy has tendinitis in right knee but expects to make next start

Brandon McCarthy expects to make his next start — and avoid a 15th trip to the disabled list — after an MRI exam on Saturday confirmed that the Dodgers right-hander has patellar tendinitis in his
Read Full Article

#39;RBI guidelines on P2P lending platform likely by June-July#39;

The Reserve Bank is expected to come out by June-July with guidelines to regulate the Indian peer-to-peer (P2P) lending market.
Read Full Article

Pepsico eyeing coconut water company: Report

The soda giant reportedly wants to buy Vita Coco.        
Read Full Article