News Reality

Berggruen Prize Winner, Charles Taylor, Is a Transformational Teacher


The university teacher, we are told, may soon be obsolete. There’s no point lecturing to a large group of students if the same material can be communicated via video. That may be true. But Charles Taylor ? the winner of this year’s Berggruen Prize in Philosophy ? reminds us that personal experience with teachers can have transformational effects on the lives of young students.

Charles Taylor is famous not just for his writings, but also for his role as teacher and mentor of globally influential public intellectuals like Michael Sandel.

Regrettably, I was never personally supervised by Charles Taylor. As an undergrad in the 1980s, I majored in psychology at McGill University in Montreal. Psychology seemed like a natural choice because I thought the field would unlock the keys of human nature. My expectations were soon dashed. Students spent their time on experiments with rats in mazes on the grounds their behavior could shed scientific light on the behavior of humans. We did not read Sigmund Freud or Carl Jung because their theories did not match the standards of contemporary science. And I learned nothing about how people think and act in the rest of the world. The field has made great progress since then ? especially in social and cross-cultural psychology ? but I knew it wasn’t for me.

Taylor reminds us that personal experience with teachers can have transformational effects on the lives of young students.

In my final undergraduate year, I happened to take a class on Plato and Aristotle taught by Charles Taylor. He had been recommended by one of my professors but I knew nothing else about him. It was a transformational experience.

By means of close readings of Plato’s “Republic” and Aristotle’s “Politics,” Taylor posed all the questions that seemed to matter (to me): Which forms of political community are realistic and desirable? Which values matter, and why? Are we purely selfish human beings, or can morality shape the way we lead our lives? Is there one form of justice, or do forms of justice vary from community to community? How do we engage with communities that prioritize different values? What is the relation between our actual preferences and ideas about how we ought to lead our lives?

Far from answering the questions, he invited students to think about better and worse answers. And he switched to beautiful and eloquent French in response to questions by Francophone students: at the time, the only professor I knew who paid more than lip service to the bilingualism of our home city. 

Which values matter, and why?

It was a large class ? about 60 students, if I recall correctly. Professor Taylor seemed kind and approachable, but I did not dare talk to him at the time (to this day, I’m still a bit nervous when I talk to him, but it’s nothing a glass of wine can’t cure). But I was inspired by his example, and I chose to pursue studies in political theory at Oxford, where he had also done graduate work and served as professor before returning to McGill. Maybe the language of “choice” is not appropriate: I was so enraptured by Taylor the teacher that it seemed like the only natural and right thing to do. Almost like falling in love: but in an intellectual sense.

At Oxford, I met two of Taylor’s students from McGill ? Daniel Weinstock and Gopal Sreenivasan ? who were similarly inspired by him (they are now distinguished philosophers at McGill and Duke). As for myself, I decided to write a thesis on communitarianism, with Taylor’s work front and center. Taylor’s writings, which I had not read as an undergraduate, spoke to me directly, not just by the force of the argumentation, but because I had memories of Taylor the teacher.

Transformational experiences are more likely in small settings, with teachers who engage with students in seminar-like discussions.

It’s worth asking if such transformational experiences can take place by watching videos or TED talks of great intellectuals. I suspect not. For one thing, transformational experiences are more likely in small settings, with teachers who engage with students in seminar-like discussions. In my case, my professional “choice” was reinforced by one year I spent at McGill as a visiting graduate student. I was part of an informal reading group led by Taylor on Heidegger’s “Being and Time,” and I’ve since used this model with my own graduate students. 

Still, I made my “choice” because I was inspired by Taylor in a large classroom setting, without any personal experience talking to my teacher. Perhaps there’s something about personal exposure to great and inspiring minds that can touch the soul. And that can happen even without extensive personal interaction with the teacher. However much I’ve become addicted to the internet since those days, I still hope young students can have opportunities for similar transformational experiences in the future.

-- This feed and its contents are the property of The Huffington Post, and use is subject to our terms. It may be used for personal consumption, but may not be distributed on a website.

Read Full Article On
OpenLedger, the decentralized exchange, has disclosed at the Money20/20 payments and fintech services innovation event in Las Vegas today that it is taking Initial Coin Offerings (ICO’s) “mainstream”
An analysis by the Pew Research Center indicates more than 4 million voters already had cast ballots with three weeks still to go before the general election, and if the trend continues, voters optin
The Walking Dead returns tonight for its season seven premiere, and someone has to die to resolve last year's epic (awful) cliffhanger with Negan. There are ten people who probably aren't going to die
“Quantico” welcomed back a familiar face last week. In the last moments of the episode, Will was seen but not with his FBI cohorts. Harry, played by Russell Tovey, tracked down Alex and Ryan’s former
One of the most famous villains in Dragon Ball Z is Frieza, a cruel sadist he acts as the main adversary to Goku in the manga and anime. Well, with the release of Dragon Ball Xenoverse 2 a few days aw
A semi-truck and a tour bus crashed in Desert Hot Springs, California, early Sunday, killing at least seven people. The Desert Sun newspaper reported at least 21 people were taken from the bus to Pal
In a new crossover between Mario and Pokémon, The Pokémon Company has announced a new line of merchandise called Mario Pikachu for release at the end of this month.
AT&T's blockbuster deal to acquire Time Warner could spur additional telecom-media mergers, innovation and scrutiny.        
The ZSL London zoo has welcomed the baby aye-aye just in time for Halloween.
ATM maker is now also supplying anti-skimming devices: Dastur
With just 16 days to go before Election Day, polls varied widely Sunday on whether Republican Donald Trump or Democrat Hillary Clinton was leading, ranging from a 2-point lead for Trump to 12 points
Despite the fact that the console industry can be incredibly competitive, it’s nice to see some of Microsoft’s executives praising Nintendo’s reveal of the upcoming Nintendo Switch console.
Intel India has a range of education initiatives — from digital literacy to skilling among older youth — and over the last year has changed its focus in this area to Internet of Things. It has create
These days my worst nightmare involves Social Security. Having written a book and co-developed software to help people collect Social Security benefits I’ve come to realize just how critically importa
The Meizu M3 Max offers a design just as good as phones by Apple and Google, but at one-third the price
We've rounded up all of the best cheap GoPro deals so you can get the best price.
The lives of the already endangered big cats hang by a thread and there are as few as 4,000 of them remaining and numbers have fallen by a fifth in the last 16 years.
It wasn’t long ago that the idea of a smart city was science fiction, but now, developments are rapid and significant.
In the paper, published in the journal Scientific Reports, the researchers said unlike graphite, which is the material of choice for most anodes, silicon can store about 10 times more energy.
“The Vampire Diaries” revealed their new big bad in the Season 8 premiere, and as promised, she has some deep roots in mythology. Sybil, played by Nathalie Kelley, is a siren who is controlling Damon
Google's Project Ara may be dead, but its principles could one day power superhuman bodies.
Want to message your friends and family while travelling… cheaply? ChatSIM offers a compelling solution for only $30… a year. Here’s how it works.
Apple is investigating a claim that its latest device iPhone 7 overheated, caught fire and destroyed a car in Australia
When the teams of Crime Branch of Thane Police were busy in raids at fake call centre in connection with the call centre scam, its mastermind Sagar alias Shaggy Thakkar was on his way to flee the cou
AT&T's track record on mergers and acquisitions isn't exactly stellar. Now it's buying Time Warner (itself the target of arguably history's worst merger), to solve its problems of maturing markets and
Scientist turned author Stacy Trasancos never stopped being a lab nerd, even after she got religion.
If you're holding out for a new desktop Mac then you might have to hold out a little longer.
Kenmore, Whirlpool, or Maytag? These washers are all great.        
‘The Robot Revolution’ has taken on a new meaning. Let’s embrace it with open arms.
How the David's of the business world are challenging the corporate Goliaths
Every fourth Sunday of October is observed as National Mother-In-Law Day and this year it falls on Oct. 23. The day is to appreciate and celebrate the woman who gave birth to your better half. Nation
Samsung South Africa says it fully supports the global recall of the Galaxy Note7 smartphones and is busy trying to track down all affected devices in the country.
It’s almost time! In just a few short hours Season 7 of “The Walking Dead” returns to AMC with brand new episodes and more craziness for Rick Grimes and his group.

Recent News

Asian sailors freed by Somali pirates arrive in Kenya for flights home

NAIROBI (Reuters) - 26 Asian sailors freed after more than four years of captivity in a small fishing village in Somalia arrived in the Kenyan capital Nairobi on Sunday, ahead of flights home, a marit
Read Full Article

Two Pakistan coast guard killed in Pakistan's key CPEC port district

QUETTA, Pakistan (Reuters) - Two Pakistan Coast Guard officers were gunned down in the southwestern province of Balochistan on Sunday in a district that is key to a Chinese-funded transport and energy
Read Full Article

Battle for Mosul can shape or break Iraq further

ERBIL (Reuters) - It has taken two years of training a demoralized army, backed up by the air cover and special forces of the world’s greatest powers, for Iraq to mount an offensive to recapture Mosul
Read Full Article

Hungary's Orban rejects 'Sovietization' by Brussels, defends nation state

BUDAPEST (Reuters) - At a commemoration of a 1956 anti-Communist uprising, Hungary's right-wing leader Viktor Orban said his country must stand up to Europe's "Sovietization" and defend its borders ag
Read Full Article

Fate of child migrants uncertain before France demolishes Jungle camp

CALAIS, France (Reuters) - Aid workers accused France and Britain on Sunday of failing more than 1,300 unaccompanied child migrants whose future remained uncertain just a day before the French governm
Read Full Article

Suicide car bomb rocks Somali capital: police

MOGADISHU (Reuters) - At least one person died and two others were injured in the Somali capital Mogadishu on Sunday when a car exploded near a camp for displaced people, police said.
Read Full Article

Venezuela congress presses for Maduro trial, escalating standoff

CARACAS (Reuters) - Venezuela's opposition-led National Assembly on Sunday vowed to put Nicolas Maduro on trial for violating democracy, days after authorities nixed a recall referendum against the un
Read Full Article

If it's Ramgopal vs Amar Singh, Ramgopal should have been there: Abu Azmi

Sacked Samajwadi Party (SP) general secretary Ramgopal Yadav is "disheartened" by the allegations that "he has joined hands with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)", said Abu Azmi after meeting him here
Read Full Article

Colleges asked to make short clips for National Unity Day

The University Grants Commission (UGC) has asked universities and colleges to make short clips on "unification" on the occasion of National Unity Day (October 31). The top three clips would be selecte
Read Full Article

Popular Finance

Tackling cyber threats

Debit card breach shows India's vulnerability to data theft
Read Full Article

Social Security Benefit Formula Robs Older Workers

Find out how your earnings history is converted into a monthly benefit.
Read Full Article

How to protect your home network - Q&A

Tips to prevent a hack        
Read Full Article

The best 4K HDR Blu-ray movies to show off your new TV

You definitely want these UHD movies in your rotation        
Read Full Article

Tour bus collides with big rig in Desert Hot Springs; 3 reported killed

Multiple people were killed Sunday morning when a tour bus collided with a big-rig truck on the 10 Freeway near Indio, officials said. A California Highway Patrol official confirmed the crash but
Read Full Article

Bring Pensions under one authority to boost coverage: Regulator

FRDA Chairman reiterated that bringing about tax parity between the NPS and the EPF scheme would provide a boost to the subscriber base.
Read Full Article

Beer Man: Sour is welcome in Bugs & Berries

Fruit beer from Boston Beer Co. and Mikkeller was made for Copenhagen Beer Celebration.        
Read Full Article

The race to 270: Which states are in play?

Campaign 2016 updates: Donald Trump focuses on Florida, where he will hold several rallies over the next few days Oct. 23, 2016, 3:20 a.m. Hillary Clinton is in North Carolina, while Donald Trump
Read Full Article

Campaign 2016 updates: Donald Trump focuses on Florida, where he will hold several rallies over the next few days

Campaign 2016 updates: Donald Trump focuses on Florida, where he will hold several rallies over the next few days Oct. 23, 2016, 3:20 a.m. Hillary Clinton is in North Carolina, while Donald Trump
Read Full Article